John Comer kept a journal of the 25 missions he flew in 1943, when the casualty rate on his base was close to 80 percent. His book is handwritten history, recorded within hours after the battles occurred. Comer vividly creates his experiences as top-turret gunner/flight engineer in a B-17 squadron that was thrown against the best pilots the Luftwaffe could offer. In 1943 the army air force had no long-range fighters to protect the B-17s as they flew deep into enemy territory. Immediate, straightforward, and compelling, Combat Crew is a classic of aerial warfare.
©1988 John Comer (P)2015 Tantor
I enjoy reading biographies of famous World War One and World War Two generals. I also enjoy reading the memoirs of the average soldier from these two Wars. These firsthand accounts by the ordinary soldier are great ways to understand these two Wars better.
Many of these memoirs are weak and fragmented trying to paste together memories from long ago. Therefore, I always am looking for those stores that are taken from a day to day diary. This is such a book; it provides us with the day to day viewpoint of a B-17 turret gunner/mechanic. Comer tells the story of his 25 mission in the early days of the American campaign against the Nazis. Comer tells us about his crew members and ground crews. I had the feeling that I was riding right beside Comer on his missions. Comer did a tour flying mission in Italy for a total of 80 combat missions. Comer died in 2005 in Texas.
I understand that with the help of his son he first self published the book in 1985. It was then bought by the William Morrow publishing company and was published internationally quite successfully. Recently it has been published as an e-book and an audiobook again with great success. Patrick Lawler did a good job narrating the story. The book is of average length of about eleven hours.
"My favorite WW II book!"
Yes, I love the book and the narrator did a fantastic job.
The story line is gripping from beginning to end.
I've read this book twice in book form and was so excited to see it on Audible. This is so well written from the perspective of the perfect position on the crew. The Flight Engineer had his hands in everything on the aircraft and it's nice to get the story from his point of view rather than the usual pilot point of view.
I don't write many reviews but I would highly recommend this book to anyone I know.
"great details behind the flying"
being an air plane nut and an airplane mechanic by trade this book covers a part of the story that I had never read before. instead of following a pilot through the missions, you get to see it from the view of a crewman. and not just any crew, the guy who kept track of the mechanical details while also fighting off attacking fighters. the crew battles with oxygen systems, electrical failures, gun jams, hung up bombs and frostbite, bringing the incredible challenge each mission was, even if fighters and flack hadn't been there.
the odds these men faced are brought out in a easy to understand way, without being boring or repetitive.
other than some odd musing in the writers mind , the book has a good flow and story, bringing home exactly why 25 missions was such an almost impossible goal in the those days.
"Excellent Personal Diary"
The first person narrative, based on Comer's diary and experiences. The story was therefore about a young man and the thrills, the shocks, the challenges, the pain and the memories. It was not about generals and strategy and logistics. As such it offered yet another valuable perspective on what war is really like.
A really good first hand account of a bomber crew member in WWII. Will be likely to purchase more titles by the narrator.
"a wonderful first-hand account"
I've read many books about World War II, including many books of first-hand experiences. I can easily say this is one of the most gut-wrenching yet enjoyable books I've read so far. Highly recommended reading, especially for Aviation enthusiasts
Good story. Firsthand personal account of each mission. Not my favorite narrator but he did ok.
story was okay. narration and presentation boring. narrator's voice was annoying and difficult to listen to.
"Best WWII First Hand B17 Crew Book Ever"
Well written first hand account of a B17 Crew over Nazi Germany. It puts you right in the action and deep into the emotions of comraderie, anticipation, and not knowing if you are going to live or die from day to day.
"this book is the best."
this book is a rare treasure. an amazing life. buying hard copy.
I could not put this book down. What an insight. Fear, excitement, tragedy, desperation, exhilaration, relief all in one book. It took you into the middle of what must have been hell at 25,000 feet. 40 below, on oxygen with 109s coming out of the sun.
"possibly the best of the genre"
A charismatic narration of an engineer/gunner's war. Probably what audio-books were made for. Buy it!
"good insight about the US airforce in Europe"
a very good info on the US airforce in Europe during WW2 and there lives
"Wonderfully Written and Told."
These Veterans have always had a warm welcome back here in the East of England.
"Facing death in a B17"
Maybe a part of the Second World War not appreciated by us who know the RAF effort but where less aware of the sacrifice made by the USAAF.
The story conveys very clearly the fear and tension of daylight raids into the heart of Germany. The incredible odds of completing 25 missions and the tension as the milestone came closer.
The description of the air combat and the camaraderie of Comers crew as they looked out for one another during the long raids. The dangers both from the enemy and equipment failures are starkly described. I have learnt an enormous amount from this book and have tremendous gratitude and respect for these brave men's sacrifice.
Hands down one of the best books I have read! Be ready for a roller coaster ride of emotions as you experience the life of a WW2 B17 bomber crew!
I really enjoyed this book. I have listened to it more than once. The narration is superb.
Those who are interested in this era are fully aware of the horrendous casualties suffered by RAF bomber crews. This book covers the period before P 51 Mustang began escorting American day bombers when casualty rates were even higher. As an account by a straightforward USA gunner it tells the story well. The account is factual and a little repetitive .
It was like I was in there with them.
A must for any aviation enthusiast
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.